Phi 270 Fall 2013 |
|
(Site navigation is not working.) |
2.1.s. Summary
The prime role of the logical word and is to mark the use of a connective, called conjunction, that serves to form a compound sentence (also called a conjunction) from component sentences that may be referred to as its conjuncts. The process of interpreting a sentence as a conjunction is analysis. We use the sign ∧ (logical and) as symbolic notation for the operator conjunction, marking the scope of a conjunction by parentheses. Alternatively, we can write a conjunction φ ∧ ψ as both
φ and
ψ, where both
plays the role of a left parenthesis. The two forms can be mixed using and
to mark conjunction and parentheses to mark scope. We will use capital letters to stand for unanalyzed components as we use lower case Greek to stand for any sentences, analyzed or not.
φ | ψ | φ | ∧ | ψ |
---|---|---|---|---|
T | T | T | ||
T | F | F | ||
F | T | F | ||
F | F | F |
The effect of conjunction on the truth conditions of the compounds formed using it may be described in a truth table showing the compound to be true if and only if both components are true. The truth table specifies a truth function, so conjunction can be said to have a truth function as its meaning. Some of the properties conjunction has in virtue of its meaning have standard names. It is commutative, associative, and idempotent (i.e., the order, grouping, and number of conjuncts does not affect the content of a sentence formed using conjunction, perhaps repeatedly); and it is covariant (adding or reducing the content of a component makes the content of the conjunction vary in an analogous way).
Conjunction is marked in English by stylistic variants of and as well as by but and similar words. Conjunction also can appear without explicit indication, particularly through the use of modifiers like attributive adjectives and relative clauses.
Care is needed to be sure that such modifications can be captured by conjunction and to identify components that make independent contributions to the compound. The presence of quantifier words can preclude analysis as a conjunction even when the word and is present.
Since conjunction is used to combine only two components, uses of conjunction to combine more than two in a multiple conjunction will involve two or more connectives of differing scope, the one with widest scope counting as the main connective of the sentence. Such differences in scope can be marked in several ways in English but such markings may be absent in a serial conjunction. Some of the effect of serial conjunction without scope distinctions can be achieved by run-on conjunctions, such as φ ∧ ψ ∧ χ, which suppress parentheses.
In all but the simplest cases, the analysis of conjunctions will find components that are themselves conjunctions. The result of an analysis will exhibit this structure using symbolic and English notation. Although it is never wrong to mark the scope of conjunction within serial conjunctions, the resulting differences in the scopes of connectives are more significant in some cases than in others.
The analysis of the logical form of a sentence can occur in stages in which we identify the immediate components of a compound, any immediate components of these, and so on. The last components arrived at are the ultimate components of the analysis; the full class of components includes them as well as all other sentences that could appear in the course of analysis (including the analyzed sentence itself). A sentence will usually have many logical forms representing different partial analyses of it.
We can specify a proposition or a truth value for a logical form by means of an intensional or extensional interpretation, assigning truth values or sentences, respectively, to its ultimate components. A sentence expressing the proposition provided by an intensional interpretation can be found by carrying out a process of synthesis that reverses the process of analysis. The truth value provided by an extensional interpretation can be found by calculation using the truth table for conjunction. The tabular notation used to write the truth table of conjunction may be used also to describe extensional interpretations and the values that they give to compound forms.