5.1.s. Summary

1

One way to hedge a claim is to make it conditional on another one, limiting responsibility for the truth of the first claim to cases where the second is true. The English word if is used for this purpose. We will refer to a compound of this sort (and the connective used to form it) as a conditional. Its two components are distinguished as the antecedent (which expresses the condition placed on the claim and appears as a subordinate clause in English) and the consequent (which is the claim that is made conditional and appears as a main clause). Although, the two components have a different significance in the compound, they can be stated in either order in English, with the antecedent preceded by if.

The rightwards and leftwards arrows, → and ←, provide our signs for the if-conditional; the two components may be written in either order but the arrow should be chosen to point from the subordinate to the main clause. As English notation, we write if φ then ψ for φ → ψ and yes ψ if φ for ψ ← φ. When parentheses are to be used for grouping along with English for the connective itself, we can use if for ← but we must resort to implies for → (understanding this to indicate material implication rather than the logical implication that is a special case of entailment).

2

In its truth table, a conditional as false only when its antecedent is true and its consequent is false. This asymmetry means that it says more as its consequent is strengthen but also as its antecedent is weakened.

3

The truth table of the conditional was first suggested in antiquity and has been controversial ever since. Current thinking distinguishes between indicative and subjunctive conditionals. The latter are held not to have truth tables (but to instead be true when their consequents are true in all the nearest worlds in which the antecedent is true). Indicative conditionals are held to have truth tables even though implicatures obscure this fact.

4

The rule of the thumb that if precedes the antecedent is the key to analyzing English conditionals, but it may not be obvious how much of the sentence is being made conditional on this antecedent. English conditionals about the future usually have antecedents in the present tense, so the tense must be changed to get an independent component with the correct meaning. When a branching conditional is stated in English, the term otherwise (which amounts to if that is not the case) is often used to state one of the antecedents.

Glen Helman 11 Jul 2012